Interviewer Shadowing: A Strategic Approach to Improve Hiring Processes

‍What Is Interviewer Shadowing?

‍

Interviewer shadowing is a method where an experienced interviewer accompanies a less-experienced colleague during the interview process to observe, provide feedback, and offer suggestions for improvement. This shadowing can be done in various ways: in-person, virtually, or by reviewing recorded interviews. The goal is to enhance the interviewer's techniques, ensure consistent standards across the organization, and ultimately lead to better hiring decisions.

This hands-on approach allows interviewers to learn by doing, in real time, while receiving feedback on their performance. Whether shadowing is used during the initial stages of a recruiter's training or as part of ongoing professional development, it acts as an invaluable tool for quality control and skill enhancement.

‍

How Interviewer Shadowing Helps (Benefits of Interview Shadowing)

‍

• Consistency in the Hiring Process: When multiple interviewers are involved, there can be significant variations in how questions are asked and how candidates are evaluated. Interviewer shadowing ensures that there is a consistent approach to interviews, regardless of who is conducting them. By establishing a uniform standard, organizations can make more objective and fair hiring decisions, reducing bias and increasing diversity.
• Improved Interview Techniques: Interviewing may seem straightforward, but doing it well requires practice and insight. Shadowing allows new or less-experienced interviewers to observe how seasoned professionals frame questions, probe for more information, and read between the lines of candidate responses. Feedback sessions post-interview provide an opportunity to reflect and refine those techniques.
• Faster Onboarding for New Interviewers: Training a new interviewer can take time, especially when it comes to the more subtle aspects of interviewing, such as understanding candidate body language or knowing when to ask follow-up questions. Interviewer shadowing accelerates this learning process by offering real-time exposure to actual interviews and immediate guidance on what worked and what could be improved.
• Objective Feedback: One of the most valuable aspects of shadowing is the opportunity to receive objective feedback. Shadowers can point out areas where the interviewer excelled or struggled, helping them recognize strengths and work on weaknesses. This feedback loop contributes to continuous improvement and a higher quality of hires

‍

How Big Firms Use Interviewer Shadowing

‍

Many of the world’s top companies have embraced interviewer shadowing as part of their hiring strategy. For example, Google uses a peer-review system where interviewers shadow one another and provide structured feedback after each interview. This approach helps them maintain a high level of interviewer skill and consistency in their recruitment process.

Similarly, Amazon has implemented a "bar-raiser" system, where a highly experienced interviewer (the bar-raiser) shadows less experienced interviewers to ensure that all candidates meet Amazon's high hiring standards. This practice not only ensures quality control but also provides a real-time learning experience for interviewers.

‍

When Should Companies Implement Interviewer Shadowing?

‍

• During Onboarding of New Interviewers: When onboarding new interviewers, shadowing can serve as an accelerated training program. By watching experienced interviewers and receiving immediate feedback on their own performance, new interviewers can get up to speed more quickly.
• For Cross-Departmental Training: Often, interviewers from different departments may be involved in hiring decisions, especially for interdisciplinary roles. Shadowing allows interviewers to learn the specific needs and challenges of other departments, ensuring they ask relevant questions and accurately assess candidates for those roles.
• As Part of Ongoing Training: Even experienced interviewers can benefit from shadowing as part of their professional development. Shadowing can be used to introduce new techniques, ensure that interviewers are up-to-date on industry trends, and maintain a high level of consistency and effectiveness
  ‍

How to Implement Interviewer Shadowing in Your Company

‍

• Create a Structured Program: To ensure success, the shadowing process should be structured. This includes clear guidelines on how often shadowing will take place, who will serve as the mentor, and what specific areas of improvement will be the focus. Regular feedback sessions should also be scheduled to ensure continuous improvement.
• Provide Feedback Mechanisms: Feedback is essential for interviewer shadowing to be effective. Ensure that shadowers provide both positive reinforcement and constructive criticism in a way that promotes growth. Encourage open discussions after each session to address any challenges and highlight what went well.
• Set Clear Expectations: Both the shadower and the shadowed interviewer should have a clear understanding of the purpose of shadowing and the specific goals they want to achieve. Whether it’s improving questioning techniques, reducing unconscious bias, or enhancing candidate evaluation methods, setting goals helps ensure that shadowing sessions are productive and focused.
  ‍

Addressing Potential Challenges

‍

One concern with shadowing is that the interviewer being observed may feel self-conscious or try to mimic the more experienced interviewer, which could reduce authenticity. To address this, companies should foster a learning environment where feedback is seen as constructive rather than critical. The goal is improvement, not conformity. Another concern being balancing time commitment, shadowing takes time, and busy interviewers might feel that they can’t afford to participate. To mitigate this, companies can integrate shadowing into the normal interview process rather than treating it as an additional task. This way, shadowing becomes part of the workflow and doesn’t burden the interview schedule.

‍

Use interview intelligence tools 

‍

While interviewer shadowing is an invaluable method for improving skills, it can be time-consuming and highly dependent on the individual providing the feedback. If the idea of shadowing seems impractical or too subjective, many organizations are turning to interview intelligence tools as an alternative or complement to the shadowing process.

These tools offer automated, AI-driven insights into interviews, analyzing factors such as tone, question balance, and even candidate sentiment. By leveraging these technologies, companies can gain objective data on interviewer performance and candidate interactions, without needing to rely solely on the feedback of a shadowing partner.

For example, interview intelligence platforms can generate reports highlighting areas of improvement, giving interviewers a clearer sense of how to refine their techniques. This ensures a more consistent, unbiased evaluation process. Additionally, these tools save time by providing immediate feedback, allowing interviewers to make real-time adjustments. For those seeking a more scalable and data-driven approach to interview training, interview intelligence tools are a valuable solution.

‍

Conclusion

Interviewer shadowing is a powerful tool to improve the quality and consistency of your hiring process. It accelerates learning, fosters ongoing development, and ensures that your organization is using the most effective techniques to find the best talent. As companies continue to recognize the value of having well-trained interviewers, shadowing will likely become a standard practice across industries.

Implementing interviewer shadowing in your organization can help not only with interviewer skill development but also with enhancing the candidate experience and, ultimately, hiring the right people for the right roles.

‍